Mark Twain once remarked of Christopher Columbus that "it was wonderful to find America—but it would have been more wonderful to miss it."
A good point he had, too.
Columbus knew what he was about when he sent word home.
"They... brought us parrots and balls of cotton and spears and many other things, which they exchanged for the glass beads and hawks' bells. They willingly traded everything they owned.... They were well-built, with good bodies and handsome features.... They do not bear arms, and do not know them, for I showed them a sword, they took it by the edge and cut themselves out of ignorance. They have no iron. Their spears are made of cane.... They would make fine servants.... With fifty men we could subjugate them all and make them do whatever we want."
Via Howard Zinn.
Oh, and there's always this classic quote on the deep deep roots of American spirituality:
"Gold is most excellent; gold constitutes treasure; and he who has it does all he wants in the world, and can even lift souls up to Paradise."
Happy Columbus Day.
Monday, October 8, 2007
Columbus Day
Posted by
Tim
at
12:01 PM
0
comments
Labels: America, Columbus Day, death
Saturday, September 29, 2007
Dialogue
Bitter Laughter continues to turn its eye to the topic of academic freedom.
And today's Inside Higher Education has a really startling piece about Ahmadinejad's speech at NYU which says as much about the state of American politics as it does about academic freedom.
Of course, this legislation isn't going anywhere. But the very fact that anybody in politics would think of penalizing an institution for promoting dialogue is simply asinine. Look at the much-watched video of Ahmadinejad responding to the question of gay rights. Is the bitter laughter of the crowd not amazingly powerful manifestation of the dialogical spirit?What Ought Whom You Invite to Speak
It’s fair to say that Columbia University has heard more than an earful over its decision to offer a speaking platform this week to Iran’s president, Mahmoud Ahmadinejad. Reaction ranged widely, with many condemning the university for inviting the controversial leader, others praising Columbia’s president, Lee C. Bollinger, for sternly rebuking the Iranian president while he looked on, and some doing both. Opinions flowed freely.
On Wednesday, one vehement critic, with a prominent platform of his own, went a large step further. U.S. Rep. Duncan Hunter, a Californian who is also a longshot candidate (to be generous) for the Republican nomination for president, introduced legislation that would “prohibit federal grants to or contracts with Columbia University.” The text of the legislation — which college officials called “unprecedented” — was not yet available on any government Web sites.
Posted by
Tim
at
4:29 PM
0
comments
Labels: academic freedom, foreign policy, youtube
Thursday, September 27, 2007
Creative Thinking
Like a lot of people, I neglect the magazines I subscribe to. When I do read them, I am usually reminded why I subscribe.
And this month's Harper's has a truly great article that offers a novel way by which we the people can stop this war: a general strike.
Of all the various depredations of the Bush regime, none has been so thorough as its plundering of hope. Iraq will recover sooner. What was supposed to have been the crux of our foreign policy—a shock-and-awe tutorial on the utter futility of any opposition to the whims of American power—has achieved its greatest and perhaps its only lasting success in the American soul. You will want to cite the exceptions, the lunch-hour protests against the war, the dinner-party ejaculations of dissent, though you might also want to ask what substantive difference they bear to grousing about the weather or even to raging against the dying of the light—that is, to any ritualized complaint against forces universally acknowledged as unalterable. Bush is no longer the name of a president so much as the abbreviation of a proverb, something between Murphy’s Law and tomorrow’s fatal inducement to drink and be merry today.What I really like about this article, too, is that Garret Keizer is finely attuned to the way in which we have become inured to this war such that "normal life" continues apace while Blackwater (and our army, too, let's not forget) shoots people down in the street.If someone were to suggest, for example, that we begin a general strike on Election Day, November 6, 2007, for the sole purpose of removing this regime from power, how readily and with what well-practiced assurance would you find yourself producing the words “It won’t do any good”? Plausible and even courageous in the mouth of a patient who knows he’s going to die, the sentiment fits equally well in the heart of a citizen-ry that believes it is already dead.
Posted by
Tim
at
10:59 PM
2
comments
Labels: end this stupid war, Harper's, Iraq, war
Tuesday, September 25, 2007
3 months until Chrismas
It's never too early to start shopping. I, personally, am already making my list.
I'm not in the habit of asking for things I don't think I deserve, and, well, I deserve this.
The BBC is already on top of this sure-to-delight item:
A former US intercontinental ballistic missile base - with a network of underground tunnels and silos, but no nuclear warheads - is on sale on eBay for $1.5m (£750,000, 1.06m euros).
Located in a remote corner of Washington state and still ringed by its original barbed-wire-topped fence, the 56-acre site is being marketed as a "gorgeous" property and potential resort.
If you know me (or even if you don't), please consider buying this for me. If you do, I'll have you over to play laser tag.
Posted by
Tim
at
3:25 PM
0
comments
Labels: consumption, missile bases for sale
Wednesday, September 19, 2007
In the news
- A flaming object has fallen out of the sky in Peru and is making people ill.
- Yet another fringe benefit for those who will not immediately perish from global warming: the receding ice has opened up the Northwest Passage.
- And, yes, we do live a police state. As I understand it, it's not technically illegal to ask John Kerry a question, but you will be tazed if you go over your allotted time. Yet the latest installment of my favorite youtube video genre, "police go crazy and taze the shit out of a good citizen." Via the Lede.
By the way, does anybody happen to know what happened to the cops who savagely tazed the UCLA student last January?
Posted by
Tim
at
1:46 PM
0
comments
Labels: global warming, the police, violence, youtube
Monday, September 17, 2007
Pure Joy
Once again Samuel Beckett proves his enduring populism and relevance across social milieus (most specifically here, across the generations).
I give you, Beckett for Babies.
Via the biggest baby of them all, Gerry Canavan.
Posted by
Tim
at
2:03 PM
0
comments
Labels: Beckett
Friday, September 14, 2007
Know Your Rights
Don't you just love those non-binding UN votes?
From Al Jazeera:
UN adopts indigenous rights billThis has been on Bush's radar-screen for awhile.The UN General Assembly has adopted a declaration of rights for indigenous peoples despite opposition from several developed states.The US, Canada, Australia and New Zealand said it gave excessive property and legal powers to indigenous peoples.
And just for good measure, a little Clash to brighten your day:
Posted by
Tim
at
12:51 PM
0
comments
Labels: Bush, indigenous rights, the Clash, youtube
Wednesday, September 12, 2007
Academic Freedom Part II: The Revenge
And just so there's no doubt in anybody's mind that academic freedom is a real issue with real consequences for delimiting what is sayable--and thus thinkable--I give you another link from today's LA Times.
Chemerinsky says UC Irvine rescinds offer to become law school deanGreat. Now administrators are so worried about coming under the watchful eye of Gestapo that they're self-censoring and hiring to please the academic police. That's just great.
The constitutional scholar says university officials told him the deal was off to head the new school because he was too 'politically controversial.' Just days after he signed a contract to become the first dean of UC Irvine's new law school, Erwin Chemerinsky was told this week that the deal was off because he was too "politically controversial."
Chemerinsky said in an interview today that UC Irvine Chancellor Michael V. Drake had flown to North Carolina on Tuesday and told him at a hotel near the airport that that he did not realize the extent to which there were "conservatives out to get me."
Thanks to Bill, Monu and Andy for the various links.
Posted by
Tim
at
7:44 PM
0
comments
Labels: academic freedom, the right
Academic Freedom and the Media
The web is abuzz with chatter about academic freedom today.
John Leo at the Washington Post hates all left wing radical professors in the humanities, and champions the work of groups that monitor their efforts to indoctrinate the youth.
A curtain has been drawn around the academy, inside of which the protection of certain favored ideas trumps intellectual exchange and the search for truth.I am reluctant to quote any more of the piece than this because it's little more than an advertisement for a group that monitors intellectual discourse for signs of partisanship. But his position is clear enough: the hate-mongering professors in the ivory tower hate America and will do anything to enforce and spread their leftist ideology.
Michael Bérubé isn't so sure. In an article at Inside Higher Education, Bérubé discusses how wrong this view of the academy is. He's part of a group entitled the American Association of University Professors’ Committee A on Academic Freedom and Tenure, which has drafted a statement on “Freedom in the Classroom" about the nature of classroom discussions in higher education and intellectual freedom:
This Bérubé piece is excellent, and a much needed reminder (for me) about the coming show-down between legislators and academics about the nature of higher education. Additionally, it is potent reminder of the way the media portrays us in the academy--as craven hippies whose sole aim is to indoctrinate the weak-mined fools that enter our classrooms with the foul excrescence of Communist ideology.The statement takes up the right’s four most prominent complaints about professors’ classroom demeanor: “(1) instructors ‘indoctrinate’ rather than educate; (2) instructors fail fairly to present conflicting views on contentious subjects, thereby depriving students of educationally essential ‘diversity’ or ‘balance’; (3) instructors are intolerant of students’ religious, political, or socioeconomic views, thereby creating a hostile atmosphere inimical to learning; and (4) instructors persistently interject material, especially of a political or ideological character, irrelevant to the subject of instruction.” In its discussion of “indoctrination,” for example, the statement argues that: “It is not indoctrination for an economist to say to his students that in his view the creation of markets is the most effective means for promoting growth in underdeveloped nations, or for a biologist to assert his belief that evolution occurs through punctuated equilibriums rather than through continuous processes. Indoctrination occurs only when instructors dogmatically insist on the truth of such propositions by refusing to accord their students the opportunity to contest them. Vigorously to assert a proposition or a viewpoint, however controversial, is to engage in argumentation and discussion — an engagement that lies at the core of academic freedom.”
This, too, should go without saying — but because it doesn’t, conservative ideologues (whose names are just at the tip of my tongue) have been able to mount campaigns against individual professors and entire campuses based on the most specious of assumptions. In North Carolina, for instance, a group calling itself the Committee for a Better North Carolina complained bitterly that the University of North Carolina had assigned Barbara Ehrenreich’s Nickel and Dimed to incoming students. Do such people really need to be told, in the words of the AAUP statement, that “it is fundamental error to assume that the assignment of teaching materials constitutes their endorsement”? Do we really need to explain in so many words that “classroom discussion of Nickel and Dimed in North Carolina could have been conducted in a spirit of critical evaluation, or in an effort to understand the book in the tradition of American muckraking, or in an effort to provoke students to ask deeper questions about their own ideas of poverty and class”? Yes and yes.
I suppose it's never occurred to the talking heads that the worst place to indoctrinate people is college, and the best is preschool. It's not a coincidence, after all, that every American child learns the pledge of allegiance at age 4.
[By the way, the academy was scrutinized in the 1980s by a group called Truth in Academia (I think) for questioning the justice of the American war on Nicaragua. Some things never change.]
Posted by
Tim
at
4:40 PM
0
comments
Labels: academic freedom, Bérubé, the news media, the right
Tuesday, September 11, 2007
It's Tuesday again
Gary Kamiya over at Salon.com is thinking about "the real lessons" of 9/11. This is a good piece because it takes the long view of how 9/11 has been used for political ends, places it in historical perspective, and incisively articulates the sense of determinism that has characterized post-9/11 foreign policy.
Petraeus' evaluation can only be "anxiously awaited" by people who are still anxiously waiting for Godot. We know what will happen next because we've been watching this movie for eight months. Gen. Petraeus, Bush's mighty-me, will insist that we're making guarded progress. Bush, whose keen grasp of military reality is reflected in his recent boast that "we're kicking ass" in Iraq, will promise that he will reassess the situation in April. The Democrats will flail their puny arms, the zombie Republicans will keep following orders, and the troops will stay.
. . .Slate.com is laying off the 9/11 story and examining the new bin Laden video, "before it is forgotten in the coming debate on Gen. David Petraeus' Iraq report." This piece is slightly alarmist; Anne Applebaum worries that al-Qaida's new turn in public relations could seduce westerners, the consequences of which, she says, would be horrific.
Sept. 11 is a totemic date for the Bush administration. It justifies everything, explains everything, ends all argument. It is the crime that must be eternally punished, the wound that can never heal, the moral high ground that can never be taken.
Real or fake, the message might still hint at the direction in which al-Qaida propaganda, or at least al-Qaida propaganda designed for the Western market, is now heading. In a recent Slate piece, Reza Aslan eloquently described how the organization's list of alleged "grievances"—which now include global warming, corporate capitalism, and African poverty, as well as the American bases in Saudi Arabia—weave "local and global resentments into a single anti-American narrative, the overarching aim of which is to form a collective identity across borders and nationalities." But the narrative clearly isn't meant for only the Arab world. On the contrary, perhaps it's time to take the main message seriously: Clearly, al-Qaida's long-term goal is to convert Americans and other Westerners to its extreme version of Islam.See yesterday's post on the new bin Laden video here.
Posted by
Tim
at
8:37 AM
0
comments
Labels: 9/11, al-Qaida, bin Laden, foreign policy, the right
Monday, September 10, 2007
The Rich
This might be the single most masterfully written piece of preeminence these eyes of have ever seen.
Then again, it could be satire. But my very inability to decide whether this is the author's real opinion or not makes the true nature of the author's intent sort of irrelevant.
Lessons that Michael Lewis has learned from the subprime mortgage fiasco.
1) The poor are "masters of public relations."
2) "Poor people don't respect other people's money in the way money deserves to be respected."
3) He has "grown out of touch with `poor culture.'"
[This point is really beautiful. Lewis wonders--in a public forum, mind you--if his distance from 'poor culture' began when he "stopped flying commercial" or when he "gave up the bleacher seats and got the suite." Yes, we all feel very sorry for you and the downturn the market has taken.]
4) "Our society is really, really hostile to success. At the same time it's shockingly indulgent of poor people."
[In this point, Lewis strains to veer his column away from farce. He proposes a 'solution' to the problem: give the poor work. "Some of these poor people must have skills. The ones that don't could be trained to do some of the less skilled labor -- say, working as clowns at rich kids' birthday parties."]
5) "I think it's time we all become more realistic about letting the poor anywhere near Wall Street."
Via Feministe!
Posted by
Tim
at
10:23 PM
1 comments
Labels: Are all rich people this evil?
God Bless the Internet
A severely underrated movie, RAD is one of my all time favorite 80s movies. This film nearly departed my memory altogether. Thank you internet gods!
(The trailer is actually less than 2 minutes and worth every second of it.)
And for the world's most radical 1980s prom scene, see here.
Posted by
Tim
at
10:16 PM
0
comments
Labels: 1980s, movies, you know...

